FSM History
Home / Contested facts

Contested facts

Where the sources give different dates or numbers, both are shown here with their sources, and which is better supported.

18 disputed facts: 13 with a better-supported value, 5 unresolved.

The ledger

18 of 18 shownDownload CSV

Contested facts in FSM history: the competing values and who gives them, whether one is better supported, and the era and island each belongs to. Eras overlap, so a fact can sit in two.
Link Fact Competing values Verdict Era Island
German flag on Yap1885 Better supported

25 August (fits Spanish arrival)

Sources: Habele; dewiki

1885 in the timeline

EraThe contact era Spanish rule IslandYap
Posadillo’s first name1887 Better supported

Isidoro (two sources) (Navy biography; MicSem; Cabello)

1887 in the timeline

EraSpanish rule IslandPohnpei
Posadillo’s death1887 Better supported

3–4 July (two sources) (Navy biography; Cabello; Moya 1891)

1887 in the timeline

EraSpanish rule IslandPohnpei
Ohwa dead, June 18901890 Unresolved

Unresolved; about 30 (Moya 1891; Cabello)

1890 in the timeline

EraSpanish rule IslandPohnpei
Spanish war cost, 1887–18901887–1890
  • 200,000MicSem
  • 14,110.82 pesosCabello
Unresolved

Unresolved (Cabello)

1890 in the timeline

EraSpanish rule IslandPohnpei
1890 expedition colonel1890 Unresolved

Unresolved (Moya 1891; Cabello)

1890 in the timeline

EraSpanish rule IslandPohnpei
1899 German–Spanish declaration1899 Unresolved

Unresolved (Pozuelo 1998; Kolonial-Lexikon)

1899 in the timeline

EraSpanish rule German rule IslandNational
Price of 1899 sale1899 Better supported

25 million pesetas (16.75 million marks) (Kolonial-Lexikon)

1899 in the timeline

EraSpanish rule German rule IslandNational
Kosrae’s low point1880–1890 Better supported

Hezel’s ~300, with uncertainty (Hezel, “Disease in Micronesia”; Kosrae outline)

1880 in the timeline

EraThe contact era Spanish rule IslandKosrae
Sokehs executions1911 Better supported

15 shot; 15 (Bundesarchiv) or 17 (Morlang) sentenced (Bundesarchiv; Morlang)

1911 in the timeline

EraGerman rule IslandPohnpei
Sokehs exiles1911 Better supported

426 (Kolonial-Lexikon; MicSem)

1911 in the timeline

EraGerman rule IslandPohnpei
Civilian Nan’yō-chō rule1920–1922
  • 1920
  • 1922JACAR better supported
Better supported

1922 (from 1 April); 1920 is the mandate year (JACAR)

1922 in the timeline

EraJapanese rule IslandNational
US trusteeship date1947 Better supported

18 July 1947

Sources: Reagan Library, 1984 message; Jensen, Pacific Asia Inquiry

1947 in the timeline

EraThe Trust Territory IslandNational
Constitution in force1979 Better supported

10 May 1979

Sources: FSM Mission to UN; Jensen 2016

1979 in the timeline

EraThe Trust Territory Road to nationhood Politics and society since 1979 IslandPohnpei, Kosrae, Chuuk, Yap
Hilo Principles1977–1978 Better supported

1978

Sources: Armstrong & Hills; Haglelgam

1978 in the timeline

EraThe Trust Territory Road to nationhood IslandNational
1983 Compact vote1983 Better supported

79% (matches counts)

Sources: FSM newsletter 1983; Wikipedia, 1983 referendum

1983 in the timeline

EraFree association Politics and society since 1979 IslandPohnpei
FSM population2023–2024 Better supported

75,817

Sources: GAO-26-107778; PINA

2023 in the timeline

EraFree association Politics and society since 1979 Recent years IslandNational
Sinlaku deaths2026
  • 7OCHA
  • 1
Unresolved

5–7 reported; final toll unconfirmed (WHO; ReliefWeb)

2026 in the timeline

EraFree association Politics and society since 1979 Recent years IslandChuuk

Timeline events with conflicting dates or figures

28 events in the timeline carry a “disputed” mark.

  1. 6 Dec or 8 Dec
    Kosrae disputed

    Lütke’s Russian sloop Senyavin arrives at Kosrae for a friendly stay of about three weeks.

    Source: MicSem ship list: Kosrae COM-FSM Kosrae outline Open in timeline

  2. Jul
    Pohnpei Outer islands disputed

    The Lambton’s crew and armed Pohnpeians massacre Ngatik’s men over two days, seeking turtle shell; toll disputed.

    Source: Wikipedia, Ngatik massacre Open in timeline

  3. 1863 or 19 Feb 1864
    Yap disputed

    Cheyne returns and introduces another influenza epidemic that kills many Yapese.

    Source: Hezel, Disease MicSem ship list: Yap Open in timeline

  4. c. 1871 (MicSem list: Jan 1872)
    Chuuk Outer islands disputed

    Blackbirder Carl carries off Mortlockese, about 20 from Satawan (Hezel) or 47 by smashing canoes (MicSem list).

    Source: Hezel, Truk MicSem ship list: Chuuk Open in timeline

  5. late 1872 or early 1873 (MicSem list: 1871)
    Yap disputed

    Irish-born David O’Keefe arrives on Yap, apparently aboard the junk Catherine, and starts trading.

    Source: Hezel, O’Keefe MicSem ship list: Yap Open in timeline

  6. 29 Jun
    Yap disputed

    Conflicting name: another COM-FSM page gives the first Western Carolines governor as Mariano Torres de Navarro.

    Source: COM-FSM, Government Administration Open in timeline

  7. 30 Jun or 1 Jul
    Pohnpei disputed

    Labor strike; Sokehs and Net men wipe out alférez Martínez’s column of about 20–24 soldiers.

    Source: Moya 1891 Cabello Berdún 2023 Open in timeline

  8. 25 Jun
    Pohnpei disputed

    Madolenihmw fighters kill Lt. Marcelo Porras’s detachment at Ohwa: 28 dead (Moya), 33 (Habele) or 34 (Cabello).

    Source: Moya 1891 Cabello Berdún 2023 Habele, Pohnpei Rebellion Open in timeline

  9. 22–23 Feb
    Pohnpei disputed

    Summary trial: 15 death sentences (Bundesarchiv) or 17 of 36 tried (Morlang).

    Source: Bundesarchiv Wikipedia citing Morlang Open in timeline

  10. Pohnpei disputed

    The remaining Sokehs and Palikir people, 426 (Kolonial-Lexikon) or 460 (MicSem), are exiled via Yap to Palau.

    Source: Kolonial-Lexikon, Karolinen Kolonial-Lexikon, Ponape MicSem Open in timeline

  11. 6 Mar (or 1922)
    Chuuk disputed

    Spanish Jesuit Fr José Pájaro and Br Florencio Mancera land on Tonoas (Dublon); MicSem dates the Jesuit return to 1922.

    Source: Jesuit Conference of Asia Pacific MicSem Open in timeline

  12. 14 Mar (or 1922)
    Yap disputed

    Jesuit Fr José M. Gumucio and Br Ramón Unamuno disembark on Yap.

    Source: Jesuit Conference of Asia Pacific MicSem Open in timeline

  13. — (or 1922)
    Pohnpei disputed

    Four Jesuits, including Frs Luis Herrera and Pedro Castro, disembark on Ponape.

    Source: Jesuit Conference of Asia Pacific Open in timeline

  14. 5 Nov (or 4 Nov)
    Pohnpei Kosrae Chuuk disputed

    Truk, Ponape and Jaluit branches merge into the Eastern Branch at Truk; Ponape becomes a sub-office.

    Source: JACAR, Ponape branch ja.wikipedia 南洋庁 Open in timeline

  15. 14 Feb (or 15 Feb)
    Pohnpei disputed

    First US air raid on Ponape, by 40+ B-24s; Japanese Wikipedia dates the first large raid to 15 February.

    Source: Pacific Wrecks, Ponape missions ja.wikipedia ポンペイ島 Open in timeline

  16. 9 Jul (or May)
    Yap disputed

    The Army’s 49th Independent Mixed Brigade is formed to guard Yap’s naval airfield.

    Source: JACAR, 49th IMB Wikipedia, Structure of Japanese forces Open in timeline

  17. 20 Sep (or 21–23 Sep)
    Yap Outer islands disputed

    US forces occupy Ulithi without opposition, guided by men from Federai.

    Source: Pacific Wrecks, Ulithi Habele, Ulithi Open in timeline

  18. 2 Sep (or 5 Sep)
    Yap disputed

    US occupation and military government begin 2 September (JACAR); Col. Eto Daihachi surrenders aboard USS Tillman on 5 September.

    Source: JACAR, Yap branch Pacific Wrecks, Yap Open in timeline

  19. National disputed

    The college became the College of Micronesia system (COM-FSM catalog dating; Wikipedia gives 1976 merger or 1978 corporation).

    Source: COM-FSM catalog Wikipedia, COM-FSM Open in timeline

  20. 13 or 14 Sep
    Chuuk disputed

    Nakayama issues 15 cholera emergency procedures, including a ban on food shipments; text dated 13 Sep, article says 14 Sep.

    Source: National Union, 30 Sep 1983 Open in timeline

  21. 11 or 12 May
    Yap disputed

    Congress elects John Haglelgam (Yap) second president and Jack Fritz Speaker; newsletter and Wikipedia say 11 May, gov.fm 12 May.

    Source: National Union, 30 Jun 1987 gov.fm Open in timeline

  22. 17 Sep
    National disputed

    Diplomatic relations with Ukraine; Croatia follows on 29 Sep (unmission) or 30 Sep (Wikipedia).

    Source: unmission.fm 1999 archive Wikipedia, Foreign relations Open in timeline

  23. 2 Jul
    Chuuk disputed

    Tropical Storm Chata’an triggers over 250 landslides; deaths given as 43 (USGS) or 47 (FSM government); Tonoas worst hit.

    Source: USGS unmission.fm Open in timeline

  24. 19 Apr or Jul
    Chuuk disputed

    Wesley Simina becomes Chuuk governor, succeeding Ansito Walter. Sources give 19 Apr 2005 or July 2005.

    Source: WorldStatesmen gov.fm, Tenth President Open in timeline

  25. 4 or 5 Nov
    National disputed

    Delegates elected to the 4th Constitutional Convention; sources give 4 Nov or 5 Nov.

    Source: Wikipedia, 2023 referendum Wikipedia, 2019 election Open in timeline

  26. 4 Mar–15 Apr
    Chuuk disputed

    Disputed Chuuk governor’s election: rival election commissions and uncounted ballots. Narruhn declares an emergency (10 Apr); a scuffle breaks out at his 15 Apr swearing-in.

    Source: Island Times Open in timeline

  27. c. 22 May (release 28 May)
    Yap disputed

    Governor Charles Chieng dies and Lt. Gov. Francis Itimai succeeds him. Chieng’s death date is given as about 22 May or as 28 May.

    Source: gov.fm WorldStatesmen Open in timeline

  28. 9–12 Apr
    Chuuk disputed

    Super Typhoon Sinlaku hits Chuuk Lagoon: over 34,000 affected and about 4,200 displaced. Death toll reported as 1, 4, 5 or 7.

    Source: ReliefWeb PHT SitRep 1 WHO Open in timeline

Notes on gaps and conflicts, by period

The contact era 1820–1885

Years with no event found: 1820, 1829

  • 1820. Lévesque’s History of Micronesia vol. 21 lists a document dated 1820 (“1820D”) about Carolinian immigrants from Lamotrek, but its title dates their arrival to 1819, so no 1820 event was entered (Habele, HOM vol. 21). The Carolinian migration to Saipan began around 1815 (Wikipedia, Carolinian people). None of the MicSem ship lists has a 1820–1822 entry for FSM islands.
  • 1829. None of the four MicSem ship lists, the HOM vol. 22 contents, or the Pacific Manuscripts Bureau Caroline Islands catalogue gave an 1829 event. The 1828 whaler Mary Mitchell at Kosrae is dated only “c.” in the MicSem list (MicSem ship list: Kosrae).
  • Undated storm left out. Girschner’s oral sources describe a severe typhoon and storm surge on Pohnpei in the “mid 1820s.” Lee Ling warns the date may be wrong and that it may be the 1868 storm, so it is not in the table (Lee Ling, Typhoons).
  • Gap in the Pohnpei ship list. The online MicSem Pohnpei ship list is cut off partway through 1858, mid-entry. Pohnpei rows for 1859–1885 come from Hezel’s disease article, Vance et al., and Lee Ling, so they cover mostly epidemics. Pohnpei’s chiefdom wars and Nahnmwarki successions in 1859–1885 are not dated in any source used here. Hanlon’s Upon a Stone Altar and Lévesque’s HOM vols. 24–31 would fill this gap, but they were not consulted for this site (the online HOM PDFs could not be opened).
  • Conflicts to keep visible:
    • Lütke’s arrival at Kosrae: 6 Dec 1827 in the MicSem list, 8 Dec in the COM-FSM outline.
    • Harriet/Henrietta: 1842 or 1843.
    • The Carl’s Mortlocks raid: c.1871 with about 20 taken, or Jan 1872 with 47 taken.
    • Cheyne’s second Yap epidemic: 1863 or Feb 1864.
    • O’Keefe’s arrival: late 1872 or early 1873 in Hezel; the MicSem Yap list instead has him picked up in 1871 after the Belvidere wreck, a story Hezel rejects.
    • Iltis flag-raising: 25 Aug per Habele and German sources, 26 Aug in the MicSem list.
    • Maigret’s stay: seven months per his diary, six per MicSem.
    • Mwot training school: 1879 per the COM-FSM outline, 1882 per Habele.
    • Kosrae’s population low: under 200 by 1880 per the COM-FSM outline, about 300 c.1890 per Hezel.
  • 1880 Kosrae king. The COM-FSM outline says “Sru I” was elected king in 1880, which looks like a slip for a later Sru, so it was left out.
  • Sources not cited. Wikipedia “Carolines Question” (2 Aug 1885) was not consulted for this site and is not cited. Every other source cited for these years was consulted directly.
Spanish rule · German rule 1886–1914

Years with no event found: none. Every year from 1886 to 1914 has at least one sourced event.

  • Thinnest years: 1888, 1895 and 1902 rest mostly on single mission or compiled sources. 1902 has one solid row (Kosrae Christian Endeavor) plus two “weak” Wikipedia-mirror rows.
  • Thinnest islands: Kosrae’s German-era events come almost entirely from the COM-FSM Kosrae outline, a compiled teaching page that warns its details differ from other sources. Chuuk has nothing between 1903 and 1907.
  • Unresolved conflicts:
    • Yap’s first governor: Manuel de Elisa (Elisa Vergara) or Mariano Torres de Navarro. Both names come from COM-FSM pages.
    • Luis Cadarso’s posting: Cabello and MicSem put him on Pohnpei from 1887 to 1891. The Revista General de Marina (Nov 2025) puts him in the Western Carolines (Yap) from 1887 to 1890 (RGM).
    • Boeder’s start: 1909 (dewiki) or 1910 (MicSem).
    • Start of German Capuchin rule: 1903 (COM-FSM) or the decree of 7 Nov 1904 (MicSem). The likely reading is that the first German friars came in 1903 and the formal transfer followed in 1904.
    • Saipan coming under Yap: April 1906 (dewiki) or the 27 Feb 1907 decree (dewiki; Habele says 1907).
    • Yap cable: laid 1904 (atlantic-cable.com), opened 1905 (MicSem).
  • Not found:
    • Exact October 1914 landing dates for each island.
    • A dated Liebenzell Mission arrival in Chuuk. MicSem says only “early 1900s” (MicSem).
    • German-era copra export figures.
    • The Woleai 1907 death toll.
    • Any Spanish post in Chuuk.
  • Partly consulted: MicSem’s Yap page is cited at the www.micsem.org/pubs/books/catholic/yap/ address, because the micsem.org/pubs/books/catholic/yap/index.htm address shows a verification screen instead. The last ~20–30% of the MicSem Pohnpei and Chuuk pages was not consulted for this site.
Japanese rule · World War II 1914–1945

Years with no event found:

  • None. Every year from 1914 to 1945 has at least one sourced row.
  • Thin years: 1916 has only naval post-office records (weak); 1925 has only branch-head appointments; 1928 has only one weak school-founding row.

Notes on conflicts and gaps:

  • Kosrae: none of the sources used here gives the October 1914 occupation date. It was never a separate branch office; it came under Ponape, then the Eastern Branch from 1943.
  • Spanish Jesuit return: March 1921 (Jesuit Conference of Asia Pacific) or 1922 (MicSem).
  • First Ponape raid: 14 February 1944 (Pacific Wrecks) or 15 February 1944 (Japanese Wikipedia). Pacific Wrecks lists missions to 6 February 1945; Japanese Wikipedia says major attacks ended in May 1944.
  • Yap surrender: 2 September 1945 (JACAR, start of occupation) or 5 September 1945 (Pacific Wrecks, Eto aboard USS Tillman).
  • Eastern Branch merger: 5 November 1943 (JACAR) or 4 November 1943 (one Japanese Wikipedia entry).
  • 49th IMB on Yap: formed 9 July 1944 (JACAR) or reorganized May 1944 (English Wikipedia).
  • 1926 school row: Japanese Wikipedia, as consulted for this site, dates the U and Ponape Japanese schools to 1926, while an earlier reading of the sources dated the Kusaie school to 1926. 『南洋群島教育史』 (1938) could settle this.
  • Not found: 1925, 1930 and 1940 island-level census tables; any typhoon in 1914–45; shrine founding dates for the four island groups; a Japanese record of the Sokehs return. The Habele pages on State Shinto and the Puluwat lighthouse could not be opened, so they were not consulted for this site.
The Trust Territory · Road to nationhood 1946–1979

Years with no event found: none. Every year from 1946 to 1979 has at least one sourced row. The thinnest years have only administrative or “(weak)” rows:

  • 1950: only administrator appointments.
  • 1954: year inferred from the newsletter’s context. Hedges was District Administrator (1953–58), and Frank Midkiff, High Commissioner in 1953–54, visited.
  • 1955: a scholarship and an administrator change.
  • 1956: one UN report plus administrative items.

  • Trusteeship date. The Security Council adopted Resolution 21 on 2 Apr 1947, and the US joint resolution followed on 18 Jul 1947. Jensen’s “12 Apr 1947” looks wrong. The 2 Apr date is widely given, but no source used here confirms it.

  • PICS name and dates.
    • Bailey Olter HS (Wikipedia) says it opened on Guam in 1947 as the Mariana Islands Teacher Training School, became PITTS on Truk in 1948, moved to Ponape in 1959, and was later renamed PICS.
    • The Francis Nuuan article says he graduated from “PICS in Kolonia” in 1951. That conflicts with the school being on Truk in 1951, so that detail was not used.
  • College dates. The College of Micronesia’s origins are dated variously: MTEC 1963 (one source says 1962), CCM 1969 or 1970, and the COM system in 1975, 1976 or 1978.
  • Senate presidency. Who led the Congress Senate in 1965–73 is disputed. Wikipedia, the FSM Government and Hanlon differ; Hanlon says Nakayama from 1968. The 1972 election page says Nakayama became Senate President after the Nov 1972 election.
  • Typhoon Ophelia. There are two storms of this name:

    • Jan 1958: hit Jaluit (Marshalls) on 7 Jan, then Ponape, Truk and Yap.
    • Nov 1960: hit Ulithi on 30 Nov.

    Placing “Ophelia 1958” on Ulithi mixes up the two.

  • Statehood date. WorldStatesmen’s “1 May 1978” statehood for Ponape, Kosrae and Yap lacks a second source. Its Truk entry reads “7 Oct 1977: Truk district” without explanation.

  • Nan Madol. Only the NRIS number 74002226 and a 19 Dec 1974 NPGallery date were confirmed. The National Historic Landmark designation and exact listing date were not verified.
  • 1946 Bikini test. The 25 Jul 1946 Bikini test (Jensen) was left out because it happened in the Marshalls, outside the FSM.
  • Not verified, so not used: a 1963 polio epidemic within the FSM (the outbreak was in the Marshalls; Ponape reported no cases by 8 Mar 1963), the Con-Con closing date (often given as 8 Nov 1975), and Chuuk damage from Typhoon Pamela in 1976.
Free association · Politics and society since 1979 1980–2002

Years with no event found:

  • None. Every year from 1980 to 2002 has at least four sourced rows.
  • Thinnest year: 1980 (4 rows, mostly the Compact and the census). 1981 has 9 rows, but two are weak (the DR-647 fire and the Faichuk veto). The National Union volumes 1–3 (1980–1982) are missing from the COM-FSM archive, so state-level news for those years is scarce.

Gaps and cautions (not events):

  • Exact dates not found: the 1989 move to Palikir; the 1991 and 1995 election days (sources say “March”); the 1999 convention referendum; the start of Compact II talks.
  • No dated source was found for FSM’s admission to the South Pacific Forum or the South Pacific Commission. A 1983 newsletter shows the FSM already paying $4,000 a year to the SPC (National Union, 30 Sep 1983).
  • No source for the Owen, Russ, Yuri or Axel death tolls was consulted for this site; those rows give only US declarations.
  • Rows citing an unmission.fm year-archive listing rely on the headline, date and summary shown on that listing page; the individual posts were not consulted for this site.
  • Rows carried over from earlier research for this site keep the URL recorded then; those pages were not consulted again.
Free association · Politics and society since 1979 · Recent years 2003–2026

Years with no event found: none. Every year from 2003 to 2026 has at least three rows.

Thinly sourced years:

  • 2012 and 2013 rest partly on archive headlines and Wikipedia.
  • 2016 and 2017 have only four rows each.

Conflicting dates kept in the table

  • Simina’s start as Chuuk governor. 19 Apr 2005 (WorldStatesmen) or July 2005 (gov.fm).
  • 4th Convention delegate election. 4 Nov 2019 or 5 Nov 2019; both dates come from Wikipedia pages.
  • Chuuk veto override. 6 Dec 2018 (Pacific Island Times), against Wikipedia’s 6 Dec 2019.
  • Typhoon Wutip. 22 Feb 2019 (Pacific Island Times, April 2019) or 11 Mar (Pacific Island Times, March 2019). The February declaration supports late February.
  • Konman’s election. 12 Nov 2021 (election day) or 29 Nov 2021 (certification).
  • Forum walkout. 8 or 9 Feb 2021.
  • Chieng’s death. About 22 May 2025, or 28 May 2025 per a gov.fm summary.
  • East Micronesia Cable landing. 18 Aug 2025 (gov.fm) or early September 2025 (SubTel Forum).
  • Sinlaku. Death toll reported as 1 (Wikipedia), 4 (PINA), 5 plus 1 missing (WHO) or 7 (OCHA preliminary). Wikipedia also dates landfall to 17 Apr, against 9–12 Apr in UN reports.

Not found

  • Exact polling dates for the 2015 elections (inferred as about 3 Mar 2015 because the Chuuk plebiscite was set to coincide) and for the 2023 elections (7 Mar is supported only through PacWIP).
  • Outcome of the April 2013 Chuuk governor’s run-off. WorldStatesmen implies Elimo stayed in office.
  • Content of the July 2026 special session.
  • Exact day of the 2016 UNESCO inscription. The decision page gives only the 40th session in Istanbul.

Sources that could not be used

  • UH ScholarSpace annual “Micronesia in Review” articles, the best year-by-year source, sit behind an access check and were not consulted for this site.
  • The Chinese foreign ministry page on Christian’s March 2017 China visit could not be opened, so that visit is omitted.
Cite this page
APA Chicago Link